This is a hard subject to write about as there are so many variables. Because of this, I am going to assume some things. You can modify them to fit your needs.
1. Lake size: Less than 1200 acres (smaller then Lake George, but big enough to need several hours to explore).
a. Usually you will not sleep in your boat on this size lake.
b. Usually you are doing activities that are 2-4 hours at a time
c. I will assume that you are doing some fishing and water sports.
d. I will assume that it is of general use for family.
e. That you need enough power to tube and water-ski
f. But enough economy so that an average middle class person can afford the gas and purchase.
g. Price range $5,000 (used) to $30,000 new
h. 16 to 20 foot in length
I. All require a trailer to tow them, possibly a truck.
2. Question to ask and research:
a. How much horse power?
b. What size boat?
c. Inboard or outboard?
d. Two or four stroke?
e. What brands?
What boat you pick depends on your needs and wants, as well as your wallet. I will describe how I made my purchase, answer the questions above with the assumptions in place.
My lake is 500 acres. It is in the top 10% of largest lakes in Vermont. There are about six or so lakes that are two to three times the size of my lake. Most people on my lake have a 17 foot “runabout†with a 70hp motor. In a general sense, this boat will tow a tube, pull young water skiers, and you can fish from.
My first boat was a 16 foot smoker craft stinger 161 (16 foot) with a 50 hp 2 stroke outboard motor. This boat was on the smaller size, but good for a 500 acre lake. You could not water ski, but you could pull a tube and fish. The boat would seat 5 people. This boat would top out at about 30 mph. It was hard to “plane†it if you had 5 people in it. It was good on gas. You could afford to buy and drive this boat. No complaints. This boat is probably a bit small for lakes bigger than 900 acres. The bigger the lake, the bigger the waves. Our kids were little, so we could fit all six of my family. It was a nice to fish off. You need a swim platform if you plan to swim away from your lakefront area. Cost $9000. This boat was purchased new as a left over in 2003.

My second boat was a bit bigger. I thought I wanted to fish more, and I wanted to water-ski. My kids were all teenagers. I purchased a 17 foot Smokercraft Mellentia Leftover, with a 90 hp. 2 stroke outboard. It was rated for 5 people. This boat was not as good on gas. When gas was around $4 a gallon, I was having a hard time filling the tank….25 gallons was $100. The 16 footer will fill for $50 and the gas lasted longer! This boat had a 4 speaker stereo system, and that I really enjoyed! It also had a swim platform. This was also fun as it was nice to swim in various parts of the lake, I could water-ski with this boat. It top out at 42 mph. It was a great fishing boat. While you could Water-ski it was not the greatest at this. If you are really into waters-skiing, I think that an inboard and/or more horsepower are needed. purchase in 2007 for $14,000

They make boats that specialize in pulling water-skiers. So if that is your main focus, focus on those boats.
So here is my recommendation based on the above assumptions:
ü 16 to 19 foot in length.
ü 50 hp to 150hp. (upper end for water-skiing)
ü Swim Platform
ü Outboard (allows you to change engine size if you wish)
ü Full windshield and Biminis top in case of rain
ü Stereo system
ü Live well for fishing
Brand? That’s a preference and financial decision. I can only say that I have seen and ridden in many high quality boats in this range of assumptions.
Search the different types of boats available. There are many websites that offer boats for sale. They also offer different categories of boats, so that you can pinpoint exactly which type will suit your needs. For instance, www.boatnationusa.com is one such site. In the boat search category, you can search for all types of boats for sale. Here you will find fishing boats, family cruisers, day boats, sailboats, and yachts. Remember the old rule about boats: “It’s a hole in the water into which you pour money.” Even a small boat will require maintenance, insurance, replacement parts, winterizing, etc. A small runabout boat can cost over $40 per hour just to run about, with gas prices high and likely to stay that way! If you’re not planning on using your boat for sports like skiing, and speed is not an issue, consider looking at boats with small motors. They go slowly, but inexpensively: $3.00 per hour of use.
Because I replaced my lake front cabin with a new house, I had to sell my 90hp boat. I now use what I started with. a 12 foot rowboat with a 9.9hp on it. This is a great starter boat. Can’t tube or water-ski, but you can get out the lake and fish. Less then a $1000 as my motor was used! Great gas mileage. The kids need to learn how to oar a boat before they drive. the basics are a kayak, canoe, and row boat. The motor boat comes later!
